Quote:
Originally Posted by MarkC
One of our apps has, just as you mention crabFish, the larger 512x512 icon with a little bit of text that the 57x57 one doesn't. However, it hasn't been rejected (although I'm aware it could be).
I think common sense prevails sometimes at ReviewHQ. If all the larger version says extra is a discreet 'v2 - Extra Effects', then they may let it go. They have with my last 3 updates anyway!
|
Well, I guess it's like everything else in the review-process... Sometimes some people get away with it while others don't - I've had a rejection based on the same scenario that you describe is working for you...
That said - you can always go in afterwards and change the large icon, so if someone doesn't want to risk having to wait an additional unkown time because they got rejected, I would suggest using that approach... Use the same icon when submitting the binary, change the large one after you get accepted...
It is better for all of us if people don't get rejected for small unnecessary things since each rejection adds upon the load of the queues - and thus the time we have to wait to get accepted (or rejected)...
